For years, ID proponents have denied that ID is just a new label for creationism. Just google the Discovery Insitute website on the phrase “not creationism.”
It is now well-known that the first “intelligent design” book, Of Pandas and People, was originally a classic “two-model” creationism vs. evolution book named Creation Biology. (See a list of the Pandas drafts, with quotes, here.) As Barbara Forrest showed during her testimony, Pandas was reborn as an “intelligent design” textbook in 1987, mere months after the Supreme Court ruling against creation science in Edwards v. Aguillard came down.
But ID proponents were undeterred. Discovery Institute spokesperson Casey Luskin bravely retorted,
No ‘word-processor-conspiracy-theory’ from Forrest can change the fact that Pandas’ arguments were always distinct from those of traditional ‘creationism’.*
...
Well, courtesy of the sharp eyes of Dr. Barbara Forrest, we have now discovered the Missing Link between creationism and ID. Since these unpublished drafts of Of Pandas and People have been introduced as exhibits in the Kitzmiller case, they can at last be quoted...In summary, we have:
Creation Biology (1983), p. 3-34:
“Evolutionists think the former is correct; creationists because of all the evidence discussed in this book, conclude the latter is correct.”Biology and Creation (1986), p. 3-33:
“Evolutionists think the former is correct, creationists accept the latter view.”Biology and Origins (1987), p. 3-38:
“Evolutionists think the former is correct, creationists accept the latter view.”Of Pandas and People (1987, creationist version), p. 3-40:
“Evolutionists think the former is correct, creationists accept the latter view.”Of Pandas and People (1987, “intelligent design” version), p. 3-41:
“Evolutionists think the former is correct, cdesign proponentsists accept the latter view.”And the creationists say transitional fossils are never discovered…
Showing posts with label kitzmiller. Show all posts
Showing posts with label kitzmiller. Show all posts
Monday, April 21, 2008
From Creationists to Cdesign Proponentsists: The Fraud of "Intelligent Design"
A recent MetaFilter thread on Ben Stein's (allegedly) awful anti-evolution documentary Expelled, pointed me to a hilarious gotcha I'd previously missed relating to the landmark "Intelligent Design" court case Kitzmiller v. Dover:
Labels:
courts,
creationism,
gotcha,
intelligent design,
kitzmiller
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)